Screen Shot 2022-11-23 at 11.40.44 AM
We are your strategic local real estate experts

Welcome to Fishers Island, New York! Located right off the southeastern coast of CT, the 7 miles long and 1 mile wide island is filled with natural beauty and charming culture. Enjoy some of the prettiest beaches on the Long Island Sound, walking trails through nature preserves! Grab a bite of fresh seafood, or dance the night away at The Pequot. There is something for everyone to enjoy on the charming Fishers Island!

Fishers Island Office Agents

Laurie Finan



Patricia Pierce



Abbie Finan



Maggie Grimes



Chris Finan



Jamie Appelberg

Marketing Director


Looking to rent on Fishers Island?

Visit our rentals website!

Past Sales

Winthrop Fort House

4 Bedrooms  2 Baths

Sold July 2020

Set on a quiet West End road on a beautifully landscaped parcel featuring brightly blooming hostas and hydrangeas, this charming home sits eager for your arrival.


5 Bedrooms  5.5 Baths  2 Acres

Sold July 2020

Perched on a hill, this home has a commanding view of West Harbor, Pirates Cove and Fishers Island Sound, and… stunning sunrises.

Halcyon House

5 Bedrooms  2 Baths  0.14 Acres

Sold July 2020

A rare find, this fully furnished wood shingled cottage is the perfect getaway.

Winthrop Drive

4 Bedrooms 2.5 Baths .50 Acres

Sold January 2020

Rocking chair porch welcomes you to this warm and relaxing West End home on private .50 acre plot.

Brooks Point

6 Bedrooms 4 Baths 2.38 Acres

Sold December 2019

Charming home with water views nestled on the private and scenic East End of Fishers Island, just a short distance away from both the Big Club and driving range.

Middle Farms Undeveloped Land

5 +/- Acres

Sold November 2019

Undeveloped East End land on Middle Farms Pond with water views. Survey Completed!

Hold the Fort

Loft Bedrooms 1 Baths .340 Acres

Sold October 2019

Right off the ferry, this adorable island cottage overlooks Silver Eel Cove.

Whistler Avenue

3 Bedrooms 1 Bath

Sold November 2019

Settle into the beauty of Fishers Island in this historic 3 bedroom, 1 bathroom Condo-Townhouse.

Castle Road Ocean View

6 Bedrooms 6.5 Baths 6+ Acres

Sold April 2017

You will relax and unwind the minute you step foot out on the veranda with incredible views overlooking Block Island Sound.

Chaves Home

5 Bedrooms 2.5 Baths 0.39 Acres

Sold April 2017

Beautiful 5 bedroom home within walking distance to town, beaches, library, golf course, restaurants, Hay Harbor Club and much more!

Montauk Hillside Cottage

2 Bedrooms 1.5 Baths .26 Acres

Sold January 2017

Two bedroom, one and a half bath cottage with enclosed porch on a lovely, breezy spot.

Stanley House & Beach

5 Bedrooms 4 Baths 2.11 Acres

Sold December 2016

Amazing ocean views and beautiful private sandy beach. This modern home overlooks Flat Hammock and the Dumplings.

Chocomount Cove Living

8 Bedrooms 8 + 2 Half Baths 2.11 Acres

Sold November 2016

Spectacular oceanfront estate, prominently set on the Chocomount Cove shoreline with breathtaking views of Fishers Island Sound.

Mansion House Cottage A

6 Bedrooms 4 Baths .410 Acres


This Shingle Hill home welcomes you with an inviting large front porch that is the perfect outdoor living space.


5 Bedrooms 4.5 Baths 5.73 Acres


This property is part of the original Olmsted plan, beautifully sited on the island's protected north shore. A long winding drive through beautifully landscaped woodlands leads to this classic ally elegant central hall colonial.

Talbot House

6 Bedrooms 3.5 Baths


Cottage #2 is the quintessential Mansion House row cottage, with a well maintained exterior that is remnant of the early days of Mansion House.

Claypoint Road

4.5 Bedrooms 4 Baths


This great mid Island house has one of the best views on Fishers overlooking the sound.

Stedman House

4 Bedrooms 4 Baths .33 Acres


This wonderful home has one of the great porches for watching the sunset on Fishers. Located near the Hay Harbor club, it is a terrific spot to be any time of the year, but particularly in summer.

Race View

5 Bedrooms 6 Baths


Race View has absolutely fabulous views, infinity pool, large yard with a daily supply of golf balls near the road (not close to the house – no worries). There is a large porch in the front of the house with a wonderful view across Hay Harbor Golf Course to South Beach and Race Rock Lighthouse.


1+ Bedrooms 1 Baths .35 Acres


A year-round cottage on an easy to care for lot.

Briar Patch

7 Bedrooms 4 Baths 5.58 Acres

Sold May 2018

Plenty of outdoor living space with expansive grounds, wrap around porch, two screened in porches and an in-ground swimming pool with a patio area and pool house.

For 7/22/2024

30 Year Fixed
15 Year Fixed
5/6 ARM

For general informational purposes only. Actual rates available to you will depend on many factors including lender, income, credit, location, and property value. Contact a mortgage broker to find out what programs are available to you.

Mortgage calculator estimates are provided by CENTURY 21 Real Estate LLC and are intended for information use only. Your payments may be higher or lower and all loans are subject to credit approval.